Lanyards

On the implications of being attached to planet Earth.

Call them what you will:

  • Tether
  • Cowstail, cowtails, cowtail
  • Personal anchor system (PAS)
  • Quick attachment safety (QAS)

Weird names and fancy acronyms do not imply intentional design.

Gravity of the Situation

“Even though cowstails are short, the choice of dynamic rope is very significant in their ability to absorb energy in unplanned falls.” ~Richard Delaney

A fall on your tether is one of the worst case scenarios for your SRT gear. Being above your anchor by any amount has severe consequences.

During a lead climbing fall, force dissipates through more rope and a secondary human. Your cowstail isn’t afforded the luxury of a squishy anchor and dozens of feet of rope.

Two NCRC Instructors mischievously joined by a common cowstail.
An NCRC Instructor playfully clipping a friend as a prank, just before he’s hauled into the air.

Why do we clip?

Known-Known:

  • You’re a clumsy skeleton wearing a magic electrical meat-suit.

Known-Unknown:

  • Waterfalls can be slippery.
  • Completely unprovoked sky-rocks.
  • The traverse you’re standing on disintegrates because geologic time includes [now].

Unknown-Unknown:

  • A squirrel being chased by a mountain lion leaps into your jacket. (Black Swan)

Tether Motivation

“Are we all actually agreed on the purpose of the tether?” ~Blake Douglas

You’re always one decision away from living a completely different life. If you hang out at anchor stations enough, you will eventually see a tether work. The author of this page has seen people slip and fall at anchor stations, one of them wasn’t clipped in.

Here’s some solid reasons to clip yourself to solid ground:

  • Feel more comfortable! (You’re nervous)
  • Make your friends comfortable! (They like you, and perhaps you’re generous with gas money.)
  • Actually not falling to your death and avoiding the ensuing wrongful death lawsuit brought by your insurance company against everyone present while they’re still grieving your loss.
A precarious cave-like ledge in Sedona. Photo: David Angel

Instant Gratification Recipe

The Perfect Cowstail

Ingredients

  • 10mm dynamic rope
  • Carabiner for short cowstail
  • Carabiner for long cowstail
  • Rope cutting tools like a sharp knife, electrical tape, and superglue or a flame.

Figure-8: The bight should only be large enough to just barely slip onto your d-link.

Poachers Knots: Set at each end, so they stay secure and tend to hold the carabiners in place. Set the knot by tensioning load and tail strands.

Short Length: Exactly 45cm from the inside of the loop to the inside of the carabiner. This will lengthen after a few uses, and also shrink after a few wet-dry cycles. This length is explained in the diagram below.

Short Carabiner: Lightweight, strong, perfect for clipping a hanger. perhaps locking (See below).

Long Length: Perfectly tuned to your body, so you can just reach and operate the top of your ascender. This will lengthen after a few uses, and also shrink after a few wet-dry cycles.

Long carabiner: Ovals give you more options for ascending devices and tend to perform better outside of a laboratory.

Tail lengths: Long enough so that your friends don’t question your tails, short enough to not be a nuisance. 8-10cm should be about right depending on the rope.


How to Measure

Take your measurement after you have tensioned your knots. Measure from the bottom of the loop to the inner-top of the carabiner.

Locking Carabiner?

The book “Risk: A User’s Guide” describes a double-bind faced by officers designing training programs for the Armed Forces.

Realistic training scenarios where soldiers are more likely to be hurt, even killed, deliver better field outcomes and potentially save more lives in battle. However, training staff are often discouraged from designing realistic trainings to avoid harming soldiers and disciplinary repercussions themselves.

Should beginner cavers be trained with higher realism and higher repercussions?

In the US, the National Cave Rescue Commission requires locking carabiners in training which likely increases safety in chaotic training scenarios.

In Hungary, cave rescuers believe it’s more realistic to have a non-locking carabiner on their short cowstail. Hungarian cavers train with this choice in mind, exercising extra care during chaotic situations.

Now form your own opinion, it might look like:

• American rescuers are compensating for abysmal basic skills or infrequent exposure to rebelays. The extra locking mechanism is a crutch which may paradoxically decrease safety, since a non-locker is always available for clipping.

or:

• Normalization of deviance has resulted in Hungarian rescuers choosing a less safe technique.

Best of both worlds? Pictured is a locking carabiner that can be easily clipped or unclipped. Everything has drawbacks, this carabiner is heavy, expensive, and potentially too large to clip some hangers. Many varieties of easily manipulated carabiners exist. Dual-action auto-lockers are another example. The author has used these for about a decade and saw this carabiner open unintentionally on rope once.

Why dynamic rope?

We’re seeking as much force limiting as possible. Your lanyard needs to be flexible, not “strong”. Skinny ropes tend to be more elastic, however we must balance elasticity against abrasion resistance. You shouldn’t automatically choose a 7.6mm dynamic rope as your tether just because it elongates 5% more, because it’s also 70% the cross-sectional volume of a 9mm rope.

Hooked Noses

The notch often gets caught during removal. You might decide you want this feature, but most manufacturers (and end-users) have moved away from this design.

Short Cowstail

Arriving at a Length

You are ascending toward a rebelay. Your ascenders stack up below knot.

To clip the hanger, your short cowstail must reach across ALL these items as they stack up under the station:

  • Croll
  • Hand Ascender
  • Knot
  • Quicklink

Typically 45-50cm is long enough. If you make it longer than this, you may have issues with your body being too far from the anchor when rappelling past a rebelay. (todo: research too long)

Often cavers believe the length of a short-cowstail has something to do with their forearm. It does not.

The Depth of Human Knowledge

This screenshot from a RopeTestLab article (paywall) shows approximate cowstail elongation figures. The author uses 6kn because of EN standards. however from reading French Lanyard Tests, we also know 6kn is about what you will experience in a fall-factor 1 fall with dynamic rope.

So the knots tighten AND the rope stretches. Lengthen good.


Chamonix 2006 also confronts this 6kn issue:

Finally it is regrettable that the most recent laws and particularly article R 233-13-20 of the Fair Labour Standards Act (added by decree on 1st September 2004) are not based on shock loads and the limit of 6 kN. It requires that “[…] the protection of workers must be assured by means of an appropriate Fall Protection system which does not allow a free fall of more than one metre or limiting in the same way the effects of a fall from a greater height.”; Yet these tests indicate that a fall of less than one metre can create a shock load above 15 kN.

A massive set of tests performed on caving cowstails

TL:DR

  • The recipe above performed best.
  • Pre-tightening knots is fine

Pre-sewn Spelegyca lanyards are more hazardous than other solutions:

An image from the Petzl Spelegyca manual. The spelegyca complies with EU 2016/425 which implies a 6kn maximum arrest. However Petzl conveniently forgets to mention or illustrate the required “screamer” for compliance.
This worker creating a mine gate has put themself into a factor-2 fall with a screamer and webbing lanyard. Taking the time to setup an anchor from above would have been ideal. Photo: David Angel

How human-like are our test loads?

TL:DR

  • Purcell prussiks are dangerous and unpredictable
  • Daisy chains are dangerous

Standards & Procedures

Europe

EN 355:2002

EN 892 deals with elongation and maximum arrest force during drop testing

United States

VTC

United Kingdom